Cristin’s Birthday Cake

My girlfriends and I celebrated Cristin’s birthday in July. We had so much fun planning each part of the day. We all wanted her to feel special and loved. The one thing that was a little terrifying to take on was the cake. You see, my friend Cristin isn’t a normal baker. She is one of the best bakers I know. Now, I have a strong belief that food tastes like the heart of it’s baker, and I believe this is one reason Cristin’s sweets are so darn delicious. She loves to bake… and all the while, she loves the person she is baking for. She doesn’t just add a dash of nutmeg; she adds a dash of nutmeg and a little prayer. She doesn’t count the cups of flour; she counts the way she loves the person she is baking for. It is a beautiful thing. So when we started thinking about who would make the cake, we all were a little nervous. Finally, taking a deep breath and a great leap of faith, I said I would try. First, step… what is Cristin’s favorite type of cake? Luckily for me, our daughters are all friends. So after a few slumber parties, I found out it was carrot cake.

Carrot cake and I have a long history and many things in common. We are both filled with spice, people either love us or hate us, and we are either very yummy or we just leave a dry taste in your mouth. And now I know one more- we are both loved by Cristin.

Two years ago I invented a carrot cake. It was invented because I was angry and hurt, so I knew I needed to tweak Cristin’s cake so that it would be made out of love. Three carrot cakes later… and a few pounds later… I was ready to make it for my dear friend.

Last week I had her over so that we could make it again, this time together. I am naming the cake after my sweet friend. So here you are… every nutty, sweet, spicy and perfectly creamy step to make Cristin’s Birthday Cake.

First, you need to gather what will be the Spicy Seven. (Really, you should preheat your oven to 375. I always forget to do that.)

Back to the Spicy Seven:

7 cups of carrots
1 1/2 cups of dark brown sugar
5 teaspoons of cinnamon
1 teaspoon cardamon
1 teaspoon ground nutmeg
1/2 teaspoon ground cloves
1/2 teaspoon ground ginger

First, grate the carrots.  I have found that 7 medium carrots are usually enough.
Loosely place the grated carrots in the cup.  You will need 7 cups.
Now mix all of the spices with the carrots and dark brown sugar. This is going to become what Cristin calls “the goodness.”

Now set that aside and get out everything you will need for the batter.

You will need:

4 eggs
1 cup of sugar
1 cup of vegetable oil
1/2 teaspoon baking soda
1/2 teaspoon salt
3 cups of flour
1/2 cup of pecan pieces

Beat the eggs with the sugar and oil. Then add the salt, baking soda, and flower. Mix well until the batter is creamy.
By now your carrots and spices will be “the goodness” that you have been waiting for. They should be juicy. Add the carrots and all its goodness to the batter and mix well. You should also add the pecans at this time. I seem to forget that step a lot. (If you do forget, you can always use them to top the cake with.)
Evenly distribute the cake mix into two 9 inch round pans.  Bake at 375 for 45 minutes.  All ovens are different, so be sure to check on it a little early and be willing to let it cook a little longer.  I just stick a knife in it and see if it is ready. You can also use a toothpick. Don’t look for a clean knife or toothpick, just not wet. Once the pans are cool enough to touch, I take the cakes out of the pans and let cool on the cutting board.

OK, now we can make the frosting. I like a simple cream cheese frosting. I make a double batch of frosting because it is so yummy and you will want some for the middle of the cake.

I am giving you the measurements for a double batch. For one batch of this frosting, say for cupcakes or something, split this in half.

6 cups of powdered sugar
2 8 oz. blocks of cream cheese (left out for a few minutes to soften)
1 cup of butter (left out for a few minutes to soften)
vanilla coffee creamer- about two tablespoons

Mix everything together until creamy.  This will take several minutes. I add one tablespoon of the creamer in the beginning and then slowly add more if needed.
OK, now we are ready to cut the top off one of the cakes.  I usually pick the one I tested with my knife or toothpick.
***This is very important. Do not waste that little sliver. This is when you get to taste the cake.
Take the little sliver and cut it in pizza shapes and dollop some of the frosting on top.

Now to frost. I am not a baker. I am not very good at frosting a cake… but I don’t know many who are. So this isn’t how to do it, this is how I do it. And if I can do it, so can you.

First, put a nice thick layer of frosting on the decapitated cake.

Now put the other cake on top. Then slather with the frosting. I usually start with the top and move onto the sides. I have noticed that if I get most of the frosting on the cake, I can smooth everything out and try to make it look presentable.
As you can see, mine is sloppy…. but it is good


  1. Shawna Lemay · August 15, 2012

    what a beautiful cake! i'm in awe! and what a gorgeous step-by-step blog post. i bet it was delicious.

  2. Anonymous · August 15, 2012

    Have I told you lately how wonderful you are? YOU ARE WONDERFUL!!!

  3. Deirdre Malfatto · August 15, 2012

    Beautiful cake, and I love your words.

  4. Andy Kennelly · August 15, 2012

    More please!

  5. Staci Kennelly · August 15, 2012

    Thank you!

  6. Staci Kennelly · August 15, 2012

    Thank you. You are so kind. You really do encourage my heart! xo

  7. Staci Kennelly · August 15, 2012

    Thank you, friend!

  8. Staci Kennelly · August 15, 2012

    Maybe.. for a small price.

  9. Cristin Spriggs · August 15, 2012

    You are too sweet!! It was a GREAT day with you in the kitchen. Thank you for your kind, kind words. I love you so very much friend. BTW, this was the BEST cake ever. I love all the goodness (and love) in it.

  10. Megan · August 15, 2012

    you are a wonderful friend!

  11. Staci Kennelly · August 15, 2012

    I am so glad you like it! Sure do love you! xo

  12. Staci Kennelly · August 15, 2012

    thank you! xo

  13. Kirstin · August 19, 2012

    Oh my goodness, this looks delicious! Remind me why you live so far away from me again!

  14. Diane · December 10, 2012

    oh gosh, you really go all the way. I think I'm too much of a “got-it-now-let's-not-waste-time- and-just-eat-it” kind of gal. I go to the trouble of making it but just plop the two layers together without cutting the head off 🙂 and most times without the icing on top — just a bit for the middle. Lazy I suppose 🙂 But yours looks so darn good!

  15. Grace Dale · March 31, 2013

    Amazing Staci – Thanks for the recipe with all the pictures. We ate the top sliver tonight and can't wait to eat the rest for Easter dinner.

  16. Pingback: carrot cake | Life in the Wylde West

Thank you for your kind words.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s